Simple and quaint, this no-frills hotel offers the standard basic amenities
Enjoy room service from the Mezetto Restaurant, the Italian restaurant down the street
Rooms are small but comfortable
Fuel your adventures with free coffee in the rooms
What you need to know
Some travelers have complained about a lack of outlets in the room
The amenities are basic, some like this, others don't
The lobby and common areas are small, making it more ideal for small groups or individual travelers
Located above a Knish deli, be sure to try the delicious pastry it's named after
Popular NYC Features
Walk to Times SquareWalk to Central ParkFree BreakfastOn-site RestaurantOn-site BarFree WiFiRooftop BarSmoke Free
Location
Across the street from Sara D. Roosevelt Park, this hotel is surrounded by a variety of cuisine from the Knish Bakery to Italian restaurants to a ramen shop. There is a subway station, 2 Avenue Station, across the street, which is serviced by lines that connect to Brooklyn and the south side of Central Park.
Rooms
Gatsby Double (sleeps 4)
Bedding: 2 Double Beds
Room Type: Hotel Room
2 Double Beds200-sq-foot (19-sq-meter) room with park views
Internet - Free WiFiEntertainment - Flat-screen TV with premium channelsFood & Drink - Refrigerator, microwave, coffee/tea maker, and free bottled waterSleep - Pillowtop bed, premium bedding, and turndown serviceBathroom - Private bathroom, shower/tub combination, designer toiletries, and a hair dryerPractical - Free local calls, safe, and iron/ironing boardComfort - Air conditioning and daily housekeepingNon-Smoking
1 Full Bed200-sq-foot (19-sq-meter) room with park views
Internet - Free WiFiEntertainment - Flat-screen TV with premium channelsFood & Drink - Coffee/tea maker and free bottled waterSleep - Pillowtop bed, premium bedding, and turndown serviceBathroom - Private bathroom, shower/tub combination, designer toiletries, and a hair dryerPractical - Free local calls, safe, and iron/ironing boardComfort - Air conditioning and daily housekeepingAccessibility - Wheelchair accessibleNon-Smoking
1 Queen Bed200-sq-foot (19-sq-meter) room with park views
Internet - Free WiFiEntertainment - Flat-screen TV with premium channelsFood & Drink - Coffee/tea maker and free bottled waterSleep - Pillowtop bed, premium bedding, and turndown serviceBathroom - Private bathroom, shower/tub combination, designer toiletries, and a hair dryerPractical - Free local calls, safe, and iron/ironing boardComfort - Air conditioning and daily housekeepingNon-Smoking
1 Full BedInternet - Free WiFiEntertainment - Flat-screen TV with premium channelsFood & Drink - Coffee/tea maker and free bottled waterSleep - Pillowtop bed, premium bedding, and turndown serviceBathroom - Private bathroom, shower/tub combination, designer toiletries, and a hair dryerPractical - Free local calls, safe, and iron/ironing boardComfort - Air conditioning and daily housekeepingNon-Smoking
1 Queen Bed200-sq-foot (19-sq-meter) room with park views
Internet - Free WiFiEntertainment - Flat-screen TV with premium channelsFood & Drink - Coffee/tea maker and free bottled waterSleep - Pillowtop bed, premium bedding, and turndown serviceBathroom - Private bathroom, shower/tub combination, designer toiletries, and a hair dryerPractical - Free local calls, safe, and iron/ironing boardComfort - Air conditioning and daily housekeepingNon-Smoking
katherinewN1650CA wrote a review on
January 09, 2021
Trip Type: Business
Amina was Amazing! She checked me in early and gave me an amazing room! Amina deserves a big bonus from the Gatsby!
Amina was Amazing! She checked me in early and gave me an amazing room. Amina deserves a big bonus from the Gatsby.
She was instantly there with a beautiful smile and kind helping hand. Very lucky...
Vgufhhjjhfcvb wrote a review on
December 15, 2020
Trip Type: Couples
Review .
Amina was great! We have stayed here before and loved it. My partner and I had a confusion with our room and she accommodated us to the fullest level of service. Love the ambiance and staff here...
Alexanonyc33 wrote a review on
September 24, 2020
Trip Type: Couples
Incredible staff, best I've encountered in NYC
After staying in several hotels over 3 weeks due to a fire in my apartment, staff at the Gatsby were the ONLY staff who made me feel welcome. Literally. I was greeted by the manager, Angela, upon...
Policies
Deposit & Cancellation Policies
Deposit and cancellation policies vary by room type and/or rate selected. Please see policy information on the checkout page.
{"web_root":"\/","webroot":"\/","environment":"production","cache_hash":"10c11a30b58fa753074a682c62b7e33792210b39","google":{"public":{"apikey":"AIzaSyDu_xle2kDllZJBKn_Y-tvcGVdRI3Q4dDE"}},"area":[],"property_type":[],"amenity":[],"booking_subheader":"","staff_pick_icon":"icon-default-hero","locale":"en_US","billing_country_code":"US","checkin":false,"checkout":false,"access_control_allow_origin":"","booking_disclaimer_list":[],"mouseflow":false,"datalayer_ecommerce":true,"content_security_policy":"default-src * 'unsafe-inline' data:; script-src 'self' *.googleapis.com *.facebook.net code.jquery.com *.google.com *.gstatic.com cdnjs.cloudflare.com *.googleadservices.com *.googletagmanager.com *.google-analytics.com *.livechatinc.com *.mouseflow.com *.gtsgig.com *.typekit.net *.typekit.com; frame-src 'self' *.livechatinc.com *.withairbnb.com *.gtsgig.com *.google.com; ","favicon":"","name":"","maxcheckin":"01\/27\/2021","maxcheckout":"06\/27\/2022","booking_engine":"ota","sort_type":"random","destination_type":"single","title_tag":"Hotels in New York City | Find Hotels NYC","description_tag":"Search for the best rates on hotels in New York City.","results_per_page":40,"feature_filter_title":"Popular NYC Features","google_map_key":"AIzaSyDV2aU10Wsfuy99VCruy-BEyaDlURtfzEs","publisher_phone":"","phone_number_call_out":"Talk to a local expert:","show_hotel_phone":false,"show_external_hotel_link":false,"display_tripadvisor":true,"soldout_text":"Sold Out","google_analytics":"UA-64498539-13","google_tag_manager":"GTM-K37LH28","guest_information":true,"billing_information":true,"patient_information":false,"additional_terms_and_conditions":"","booking_disclaimer":"","privacy_policy_url":"","terms_of_use_url":"","currency":"USD","show_fee_breakdown":true,"promotion_required":false,"minimum_promotion_percent":"","gdpr_cookie_consent":true,"shopping_cart":false,"shopping_cart_modal_box":false,"shopping_cart_store_id":"","shopping_cart_token":"","ean_parity_control":false,"powered_by_rootrez_link":true,"show_accommodation_publisher_description":false,"google_tag_manager_2":"","feature_filters":[{"id":257,"name":"Walk to Times Square","icon":"near-times-quare"},{"id":259,"name":"Walk to Central Park","icon":"near-central-park"},{"id":6,"name":"Free Breakfast","icon":"food"},{"id":5,"name":"On-site Restaurant","icon":"food"},{"id":28,"name":"On-site Bar","icon":"drink"},{"id":32,"name":"Free WiFi","icon":"free-wifi"},{"id":260,"name":"Rooftop Bar","icon":"rooftop-bar"},{"id":256,"name":"Smoke Free","icon":"no-smoking"}],"assets":"\/assets\/lodging.findhotels\/","dirname":"lodging.findhotels","domain":"lodging.findhotels.nyc","url_base":"lodging.findhotels.nyc","single_hotel_pin_color":"#6DC234","allowed_filters":{"destinations":[{"id":122,"name":"Brooklyn","country":"US","region":"New York","permalink":"\/search\/122\/us\/new-york\/brooklyn","children":[{"id":685,"name":"Bedford-Stuyvesant"},{"id":686,"name":"Boerum Hill"},{"id":687,"name":"Bushwick"},{"id":688,"name":"Downtown Brooklyn"},{"id":689,"name":"Park Slope"}]},{"id":237,"name":"Manhattan","country":"US","region":"New York","permalink":"\/search\/237\/us\/new-york\/manhattan","children":[{"id":650,"name":"Battery Park City"},{"id":651,"name":"Chelsea"},{"id":652,"name":"Chinatown"},{"id":653,"name":"East Village"},{"id":654,"name":"Flatiron District"},{"id":655,"name":"Garment District"},{"id":656,"name":"Greenwich Village"},{"id":657,"name":"Harlem"},{"id":658,"name":"Hells Kitchen"},{"id":659,"name":"Herald Square"},{"id":660,"name":"Hudson Square"},{"id":661,"name":"Hudson Yards"},{"id":662,"name":"Kips Bay"},{"id":663,"name":"Lower East Side"},{"id":664,"name":"Lower Manhattan"},{"id":665,"name":"Meatpacking District"},{"id":666,"name":"Midtown"},{"id":667,"name":"Midtown East"},{"id":668,"name":"Midtown West"},{"id":669,"name":"Murray Hill"},{"id":670,"name":"Nolita"},{"id":671,"name":"Nomad"},{"id":672,"name":"Soho"},{"id":673,"name":"Times Square\/Theater District"},{"id":674,"name":"Tribeca"},{"id":675,"name":"Union Square"},{"id":676,"name":"Upper East Side"},{"id":677,"name":"Upper West Side"}]},{"id":121,"name":"New York City","country":"US","region":"New York","permalink":"\/search\/121\/us\/new-york\/new-york-city","children":[{"id":239,"name":"Queens","children":[{"id":243,"name":"Long Island City"},{"id":240,"name":"JFK Airport"},{"id":241,"name":"Kew Garden Hills"},{"id":242,"name":"LaGuardia Airport"}]},{"id":232,"name":"Brooklyn","children":[{"id":233,"name":"Boreum Hill"},{"id":235,"name":"Downtown Brooklyn"},{"id":236,"name":"Gowanus"},{"id":237,"name":"Sunset Park"},{"id":238,"name":"Williamsburg"},{"id":234,"name":"Brooklyn Heights"}]},{"id":210,"name":"Manhattan","children":[{"id":201,"name":"Midtown"},{"id":203,"name":"Lower Manhattan"},{"id":212,"name":"Chinatown"},{"id":213,"name":"Garment District"},{"id":214,"name":"Greenwich Village"},{"id":215,"name":"Gramercy Park"},{"id":216,"name":"Harlem"},{"id":217,"name":"Hell's Kitchen\/Midtown West"},{"id":218,"name":"Herald Square"},{"id":219,"name":"Hudson Square"},{"id":220,"name":"Kips Bay"},{"id":221,"name":"Lower East Side"},{"id":222,"name":"Midtown East"},{"id":223,"name":"Murray Hill"},{"id":224,"name":"Upper East Side"},{"id":225,"name":"Upper West Side"},{"id":226,"name":"NoMad"},{"id":227,"name":"Nolita"},{"id":228,"name":"SoHo"},{"id":229,"name":"Times Square\/Theatre District"},{"id":230,"name":"Tribeca"},{"id":231,"name":"Union Square"}]},{"id":247,"name":"Morristown","children":[{"id":249,"name":"Downtown Morristown"},{"id":248,"name":"Morris Plains"}]},{"id":250,"name":"Jersey City","children":[{"id":252,"name":"Exchange Place North"},{"id":251,"name":"The Waterfront"}]},{"id":253,"name":"Bloomfield"},{"id":254,"name":"Westchester"},{"id":381,"name":"Chelsea"},{"id":409,"name":"Elizabeth\/Newark"},{"id":494,"name":"Waterloo"},{"id":590,"name":"Rockaway Beach"}]},{"id":123,"name":"Queens","country":"US","region":"New York","permalink":"\/search\/123\/us\/new-york\/queens","children":[{"id":679,"name":"Elmhurst"},{"id":680,"name":"Flushing"},{"id":681,"name":"Fresh Meadows"},{"id":682,"name":"Jamaica"},{"id":683,"name":"Long Island City"}]},{"id":127,"name":"Staten Island","country":"US","region":"New York","permalink":"\/search\/127\/us\/new-york\/staten-island","children":[{"id":253,"name":"Bloomfield"}]},{"id":238,"name":"Surrounding Areas","country":"US","region":"New York","permalink":"\/search\/238\/us\/new-york\/surrounding-areas","children":[{"id":691,"name":"Hoboken"},{"id":692,"name":"New Brunswick"},{"id":693,"name":"Morristown"},{"id":694,"name":"Rockaway Beach"},{"id":695,"name":"Saratoga Springs"},{"id":696,"name":"Waterloo"},{"id":697,"name":"Westchester"},{"id":698,"name":"Newark"}]}],"sort_by":["Recommended","Rating","Name","Price"]},"organization":"HANYC","map":{"terrian":"roadmap","zoom":12,"latitude":40.723136,"longitude":-73.990234,"style":[{"featureType":"poi.business","stylers":[{"visibility":"off"}]},{"featureType":"poi.medical","stylers":[{"visibility":"off"}]}],"pins":[]}}
Star-ratings are a way you can learn what to generally expect in regards to quality and service when you book a hotel. Five-stars is the highest rating.
5 stars: No detail is left unaccounted for at these breathtaking luxury hotels. With a plethora of amenities, above-and-beyond accommodations, and stellar service, you’ll feel like royalty during your stay.
4 stars: These outstanding hotels offer a high degree of accommodation, premium in-room amenities, facilities and service.
3 stars: The hotels offer quality accommodations with a good selection of in-room amenities, facilities and service.
2 stars: These hotels provide good value with modest accommodations, adequate in-room amenities, facilities and service. Offering limited extras, these hotels are affordably priced.
This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience.
Learn More
